Pulled Chicken Chile Relleno Stuffed /w Jalapeno Popper
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
For a special Cinco de Mayo (Spanish for “fifth of May”) treat, I’ve concocted something that is so good you may want to cry . . .well, maybe, but you’ll be hard pressed to taste anything so amazing. I’ve combined the ever popular Jalapeno Popper barbecue appetizer (aka Atomic Buffalo Turds ABTs) with an old school Chile Relleno. I had some barbecue chicken left over from my Reserve Champion win last Saturday at the Sams Regional Finals in Vegas so I shredded the chicken and mixed it with some Jack cheese and stuffed it into a roasted Poblano chili which was stuffed with an ABT with a full slice of bacon and my 1st place KCBS 2012 Chicken TOY SYD Chicken Rub. Reserve Champion at Sam’s Regional Finals in Vegas, April 2014

I doused it in a airy egg batter and lovingly fried it to a golden hue before bathing it in a heavenly tomato-onion-chicken-cinnamon-clove sauce. Add the supporting cast of some green cilantro, white queso fresco (fresh Mexican cheese), and more sauce and I began to visualize the colors of the Mexican flag. Mmmm . . . the flavors melded so wonderfully that it’ll make you cry, go loco, fall in love, and thought you died and gone to Heaven! Roasted chiles, barbecue chicken, cheese, sauce, bacon . . .
Recipe type: Entree
Cuisine: Mexican
Serves: 4
  • Sauce: If you’re short on time, you can use store-bought salsa–just add in the chicken broth, cinnamon & cloves.
  • 1 tbsp light olive oil (or your favorite cooking oil / lard)
  • 1 small onion (or ½ of a medium to large onion); diced
  • 1 twenty-eight oz can of whole tomatoes, including juice
  • 1 jalapeno; seeds/veins removed & minced (add more if you like spicy)
  • 2 garlic gloves; minced
  • 1 cup chicken stock (canned, from bullion or homemade)
  • ¼ tsp cinnamon (or ¼ of a stick)
  • 2 cloves
  • salt & pepper to taste
  • ABT’s (below)
  • Pulled Chicken & Shredded Monterey Jack Mixture (below)
  • 4 jalapenos
  • ¼ pkg cream cheese
  • 4 slices of bacon
  • SYD chicken rub
  • Pulled Chicken & Shredded Montery Jack Mixture:
  • 1 cup Pulled BBQ Chicken
  • 4 oz grated Monterey Jack
  • 4 Poblano chiles
  • Stuffing (above)
  • All Purpose White Flour
  • 4 Egg Whites
  • 4 Egg Yolks
  • ¼ teaspoon white flour
  • Oil
  • salt & pepper to taste
  • Cilantro
  • Queso Fresco
  • Sauce (above)
  1. Add the cooking oil to a frying pan and heat on medium high.
  2. Once oil is heated, add in the diced onions. Saute onions until browned and slightly caramelized

    Saute until translucent

  3. Place into a blender the following: can of whole tomatoes w/ juice, the sauteed onions, minced jalapeno, and minced garlic.
  4. Pulse the blender a few times until the tomatoes & onions are to your liking–usually two to three seconds.
  5. Return the contents of the blender to the pan you sauteed the onions in along with the chicken stock, cinnamon & cloves.
  6. Bring to a simmer on high then reduce heat to medium low. Simmer until sauce is desired consistency (10-15 minutes usually—depending on stove heat).
  7. Salt & pepper to taste
  8. Remove spent cloves.

    I like it chunky smooth. Pulse less if you like chunky

  9. Stuffing:
  10. Cut tops off jalapenos.
  11. Core out jalapenos with butter knife (or coring tool).
  12. Stuff jalapeno with cream cheese. Note: don’t pack too tightly as the cream cheese needs room to expand.
  13. Wrap with a full slice of bacon and toothpick the end.
  14. Sprinkle on SYD chicken rub to your liking.
  15. Cook at 350-400F for 25-30 minutes on the kettle, indirect.
  16. Pull off the grill, set aside and let cool down
  17. Pulled Chicken & Shredded Montery Jack Mixture:
  18. BBQ the chicken with SYD chicken rub. (Alternatively you can grill or even purchase a pre-cooked rotisserie chicken from Walmart.)
  19. Let the chicken cool down. (Refrigerate if needed.)
  20. Grate the Monterey Jack cheese.
  21. Combine grated cheese with chicken; cover and set aside. (Refrigerate if needed.)
  23. Fill a chimney full of charcoal and let it get red hot & flaming all the way to the top
  24. Dump charcoal into one side of a grill (e.g. 22” Weber kettle) – banked
  25. Put the cooking grate on and let it heat up with hood on for a few minutes then clean
  26. Fire roast the chiles over the flaming hot briquettes with the kettle lid off. Roast long enough to peel the skin off easily but not too long as to have the chiles fall apart easily.
  27. Once cooked, place in a bag and let steam for around 10 minutes.
  28. Scrape off cooked chile skins with a knife and/or use fingers.
  29. Make a slit down the chile about ⅔rds of the way.
  30. Remove veins and seeds with knife and/or hands.
  31. Lay in a thin layer of the chicken/jack cheese mixture.
  32. Lay an ABT inside over that layer.
  33. Then put more cheese & chicken over the ABT, just enough to allow the chiles to at least mostly close up.
  34. Once all chiles are stuffed, carefully dredge them in flour and set aside.
  35. Separate the egg yolks from whites. (An easy way is to carefully crack the egg into a small bowl and fish out the yolk with a spoon, as shown in the two photos provided.) [url href="http://www.slapyodaddybbq.com/wp-content/uploads/81_DSC_0005.jpg"][/url]
  36. Put the whites in a mixing bowl (for use with either hand mixer or stand mixer).
  37. Whisk on high speed for a good minute or more until you have stiff peaks—add in a pinch or two of white flour while this is mixing.
  38. Turn the mixer speed down to stir and add in the egg yolk. Mix for a short while then remove mixing bowl. Take a wooden spoon or silicone spatula and fold in any egg yolk that didn’t fully combine.
  39. Heat up a cast iron skillet with about ¼ to ½ inch of cooking oil to 350F, then reduce heat to medium.
  40. Dip the floured stuffed pablano into the batter being careful not to lose any of the stuffing. You can just coat one side then sit in the hot oil, then proceed to coat the other side while it is frying, using your wooden spoon or silicone spatula.
  41. With a spatula, gently flip (danger hot oil) the chiles rellenos after one side gets golden brown—about a couple minutes or so.
  42. Let the other side get golden brown as well, then flip on its side to even out the golden crust.
  43. You can keep flipping it as many times as you like until you are satisfied with the overall goldenness.
  44. Then put the chiles rellenos on a cooling / wire rack over a tray to catch any grease.
  45. Once they are cooked you can serve immediately or let cool down, wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate or freeze. To heat up at a later time, thaw first if frozen, and preheat your oven to 400F and cook for about 10-15 minutes.
  46. Serve with refried beans & rice. Garnish with cilantro, queso fresco and the sauce.
Recipe by Slap Yo' Daddy BBQ at https://www.slapyodaddybbq.com/2014/05/pulled-chicken-chili-relleno-stuffed-w-jalapeno-popper/